Heeling Problem Solving: Regaining Focus with the E-Collar

A chocolate Labrador retriever sits outdoors wearing a leather collar, bathed in warm sunlight.

Hey everyone,

The concept behind gun dog training is to capture and maintain your dog’s focus on you, and so, if your dog is sniffing the ground while you’re teaching him to heel then obviously you are not maintaining that focus. Let me teach you how to get that focus back: It’s important that your dog understand…

Heeling is a fundamental obedience skill for any dog, but it’s especially crucial for retrievers who need to be reliably under control in various hunting and field trial situations. One of the most common challenges trainers face is a dog that loses focus and breaks heel, often distracted by scents on the ground. Let’s explore how to address this problem, keeping in mind the responsible and ethical use of the electronic training collar (e-collar).

The Importance of Focus in Heeling

A solid heel isn’t just about your dog walking politely by your side; it’s about focus and communication. When your dog is truly heeling, they’re paying attention to you, responding to your cues, and maintaining their position regardless of distractions.

If your dog is sniffing the ground, lagging behind, or forging ahead, they’re not truly heeling. They’re simply walking nearyou, but their mind is elsewhere.

Understanding the Root of the Problem

Before reaching for the e-collar, it’s essential to understand why your dog is breaking heel. Common causes include:

  • Lack of Foundation: The dog may not have a solid understanding of the heeling command.
  • Distractions: The environment may be too stimulating for the dog to maintain focus.
  • Boredom: The training sessions may be too long or repetitive, leading to boredom and disengagement.
  • Inconsistent Cues: You may be giving unclear or inconsistent cues, confusing the dog.
  • Lack of Motivation: The dog may not be sufficiently motivated to heel properly.

Addressing the Problem Without the E-Collar First

Before introducing the e-collar, try these techniques:

  • Review the Basics: Go back to the basics of heeling training. Use positive reinforcement to reward correct behavior.
  • Reduce Distractions: Train in a less stimulating environment. Gradually introduce distractions as the dog progresses.
  • Increase Engagement: Use high-value treats or toys to keep your dog engaged and motivated.
  • Vary Training Sessions: Keep training sessions short, fun, and varied to prevent boredom.
  • Clear and Consistent Cues: Use clear and consistent verbal and hand cues.
  • Proper Leash Handling: Use the leash to gently guide your dog into the correct heeling position.

If these methods are successful, you may not need to use the e-collar at all.

Using the E-Collar to Reinforce Focus (Responsibly)

If your dog understands the heeling command but continues to break focus despite your best efforts, the e-collar can be used to reinforce the command. Remember, the goal is not to punish the dog, but to redirect their attention back to you.

Here’s how to use the e-collar to address heeling problems:

  1. Ensure Proper Fit and Working Level: As always, make sure the e-collar fits properly and you’ve identified your dog’s working level (the lowest level they can perceive).
  2. Give the Heel Command: Start by giving the “Heel” command.
  3. Anticipate the Break: Watch for signs that your dog is about to lose focus (e.g., sniffing the ground, lagging behind).
  4. Gentle Reminder: The instant your dog starts to break heel, deliver a brief and mild stimulation at their working level.
  5. Immediate Correction: At the same time as the stimulation, give a clear verbal cue (“Heel!”) and gently correct the leash.
  6. Positive Reinforcement: The instant your dog returns to the correct heeling position and makes eye contact, immediately stop the stimulation and offer enthusiastic praise (“Good heel!”) and/or a treat.

Key Points to Remember:

  • Timing is Crucial: The stimulation must be delivered the moment the dog starts to break heel, not after they’ve already wandered off.
  • Low-Level Stimulation: Use the lowest level of stimulation that gets your dog’s attention.
  • Pair with Verbal Cue: Always use the verbal cue (“Heel!”) in conjunction with the stimulation.
  • Positive Reinforcement is Essential: Praise and reward the desired behavior.
  • Fade the Stimulation: As your dog becomes more consistent, gradually reduce the frequency and intensity of the stimulation.

Troubleshooting Common Problems

  • Dog is Fearful: If your dog shows signs of fear or anxiety, reduce the stimulation level or discontinue e-collar training altogether.
  • Dog is Ignoring the Stimulation: Increase the stimulation level slightly, but be careful not to overdo it.
  • Dog is Confused: Make sure your commands are clear and consistent. Go back to the basics of heeling training if necessary.

Alternatives to the E-Collar

If you’re uncomfortable using an e-collar, or if it’s not working for your dog, consider these alternatives:

  • Clicker Training: Use a clicker to mark the desired behavior and then reward with a treat.
  • Long Line Training: Use a long line to maintain control and guide your dog into the correct heeling position.
  • Professional Trainer: Seek guidance from a qualified dog trainer who specializes in positive reinforcement methods.

Conclusion: Finding What Works Best

The e-collar can be a useful tool for addressing heeling problems, but it’s not the only solution. The key is to understand the root cause of the problem, try alternative methods first, and use the e-collar responsibly and ethically, if at all. Ultimately, the best approach is the one that works best for you and your dog, building a strong bond of trust and communication along the way.

Scroll to Top